Car insurance market dysfunctional, says Aviva

Posted on by CCKeith in Uncategorized Comments Off on Car insurance market dysfunctional, says Aviva

The car insurance market is “dysfunctional” and does not reward loyal customers, said the chief executive of Aviva, Mark Wilson.

He said firms were tempting in new customers with prices that were “too low”, which put prices up for existing customers.

Car insurance premiums have gone up by 11% in the last year, according to the Association of British Insurers (ABI).

The typical bill for an annual policy is now £484, it said.

“I think that the UK car insurance market is dysfunctional, I don’t think it works properly,” Mr Wilson told the BBC’s Today Programme.

“The entry level is too low and then it gets put up for all existing customers,” he said.

Aviva has developed a “suite” of products to be launched before the end of the year, which will help reward loyal customers.

“Let’s see how it goes,” Mr Wilson said.

Car insurance is just 2% of Aviva’s total business.


Shares in Aviva rose by about 0.5%, after the company reported operating profits up by 8% in the first half of 2017.

Sales of annuities, bulk annuities and equity release products all rose, with growth particularly strong in the UK.

The dividend was up by 13%.

However, Mr Wilson refused to say whether he thought he was paid too much.

“I think I’ll let the shareholders answer that one,” he told the BBC.

He said the company was happy to publish the ratio of its highest paid employee to its lowest, as soon as the government had determined how such a ratio should be expressed.

Aviva already pays its employees the National Living Wage and requires all its contractors to do likewise.

Aviva says you’ve got it wrong: Most life insurance claims are accepted

Posted on by CCKeith in Uncategorized Comments Off on Aviva says you’ve got it wrong: Most life insurance claims are accepted

A report from the insurer says more than 95 per cent of claims are paid, but it isn’t telling the whole story 

In theory, having insurance to protect your family against loss of life, or a critical illness, is a thoroughly good idea.

The trouble is, to get it you have to deal with an insurance company. Most people don’t have a great deal of trust them or in the policies that they sell.

Aviva, Britain’s biggest, has released details of a survey that illustrates the problem. It found that just 47 per cent of respondents think insurers will pay out when this sort of policy is claimed against.

If those results are reflective of the views of the population at large, then one in every two Britons effectively think that life insurnace is worthless.

An even higher proportion, some  86 per cent, think (surprise surprise) that insurers will always try and avoid paying out.

Aviva, however, would like you to know that you’re wrong if you’re among their number.

“Aviva data shows very few individual protection claims go unpaid: 96.7% of all claims across life insurance, critical illness and income protection were paid in 2016,” it says. And there’s more. Some £870m was paid out last year – about £2.4m per day.

So why the disconnect? Aviva thinks people are ill informed and that the industry should work to scotch the “pervasive myth” that claims frequently go unpaid.

As is often the case with reports like the one it has produced, and they regularly emanate from the life insurance industry, there is some truth in what the company has to say. It’s just not the whole truth.

The reason people think insurers don’t pay is because they probably know someone who has either had a claim denied, or who has endured a bad experience before getting one paid. Or part paid. That 3.3 per cent of claims Aviva says are denied? It still amounts to quite a lot of claims in practice.

And it’s not just life insurance that causes problems. Calling an insurer about any claim, on any policy, can often be a thoroughly miserable experience.

Aviva would probably argue that life insurance isn’t home insurance. Or car insurance. It’s handled by a different department.

Most people understandly struggle to make that distinction. And why should they? Insurance is insurance, after all. It’s often sold be the same people, and they’re not always very nice when customers need them.

Customer service often isn’t what it might be and getting into a fight with an insurer can rapidly get unpleasant. It isn’t like calling Amazon to say your order hasn’t turned up, or highlighing poor service at a supermarket and getting a £50 voucher for your trouble. I speak from bitter personal experience.

The trouble with reports like this is that the industry fails to recognise this.

Aviva complains that 30 per cent of people admit to cheating on insurance forms, and they shouldn’t.

But I’d imagine the average Briton doesn’t see it as terribly immoral to try and get one over an industry that so often seems to be set upon getting one over on the average Briton.

Then there is the process of applying for protection policies. It can be both highly intrusive, and very unpleasant. Policy documents often contain a lot of legalese, even if efforts have been made (after some prodding from regulators) to make key features documents easier to understand.

It is an industry failing that very few of its senior people see this. Very few are ever willing to admit that their industry is anything other than a paragon, despite a long history of disciplinary issues with watchdogs.

Paul Brencher, managing director of individual protection at Aviva, says it all in his comments released on the back of the report. “Claims rates could be even higher if all consumers were aware of the need to take extra care when making an application,” he argues. “Incorrect information, whether deliberate or accidental, and not checking the product details are some of the main reasons why a small proportion of protection claims cannot be paid.”

So it’s all your fault if something goes wrong and nothing to do with Mr Brencher and his colleagues, who rarely acknowledge the profound power imbalance at play between the industry and its customers. If any “extra care” is needed with the forms, it should really come from his side. If forms have a habit of tripping people up, then that needs to be addressed.

Life insurance? It is a good idea if you’re insurable (medical profiling is increasingly winnowing people out, which is another problem). More people should probably have it than do. But it’s all too easy to understand why they don’t much like the idea of buying it from an industry that just doesn’t get it

Privacy Preference Center

Close your account?

Your account will be closed and all data will be permanently deleted and cannot be recovered. Are you sure?

Switch to mobile version